Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 28, 2023 20:57:25 GMT
Taking all things into account - for me it's the Border Collie.
|
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 28, 2023 21:35:06 GMT
What are all the things you took into account?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 28, 2023 22:48:08 GMT
What are all the things you took into account? Oh you know, just the usual. (I literally have no idea) Sent from my SM-A105FN using Tapatalk |
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 28, 2023 23:00:40 GMT
Lol, I was hoping we could establish some kind of set of criteria, then we could score the dogs in each category and determine a winner. Maybe we should think about that.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 28, 2023 23:07:54 GMT
Lol, I was hoping we could establish some kind of set of criteria, then we could score the dogs in each category and determine a winner. Maybe we should think about that. You can make the criteria. I'm not a dog guy. Sent from my SM-A105FN using Tapatalk |
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 28, 2023 23:21:20 GMT
What makes for a good snake then?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 28, 2023 23:46:27 GMT
What makes for a good snake then? Alright fine I'll help. So when I was thinking of the Collie. I was picturing their impressive *athletic abilities* - they're often seen as one of the 'dogs of choice' for circuits and timed races and can troll around cattle and sheep, *high intelligence* - often regarded as the smartest dog breed, being able to follow more strategical and advanced requests when compared to other dog breeds, *family-friendliness* - respects people, doesn't get into tussles with other dogs as much as other breeds do, + obeys owner at most times, and for their exceptional *herding skills* (do I need to explain?). So what I mean here is that, in short and for example, a Kangal may be a great Guardian dog - no doubt - but it would fall short on said points listed above (circuits, family...). Which brings its overall status down a bit. What were you thinking? Sent from my SM-A105FN using Tapatalk |
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 29, 2023 2:16:58 GMT
What makes for a good snake then? Alright fine I'll help. So when I was thinking of the Collie. I was picturing their impressive *athletic abilities* - they're often seen as one of the 'dogs of choice' for circuits and timed races and can troll around cattle and sheep, *high intelligence* - often regarded as the smartest dog breed, being able to follow more strategical and advanced requests when compared to other dog breeds, *family-friendliness* - respects people, doesn't get into tussles with other dogs as much as other breeds do, + obeys owner at most times, and for their exceptional *herding skills* (do I need to explain?). So what I mean here is that, in short and for example, a Kangal may be a great Guardian dog - no doubt - but it would fall short on said points listed above (circuits, family...). Which brings its overall status down a bit. What were you thinking? Sent from my SM-A105FN using Tapatalk I dunno, it's actually something I have thought about a lot but struggled to figure out. A comprehensive list of attribute categories that really covers everything. I have tried and failed in the past. Let me try again Body-Skin durability feet durability Bone durability Skull durability Coat durability Muscle/fat durability Agility Jumping Flexibility Explosivity Power Power-to-Weight Endurance Energy Height/Length Mass "Fuel" Economy Pain tolerance Cold tolerance Heat tolerance Running-Top speed Acceleration Sprint sustenation Lateral Movement Long distance Mouth-Snap force Crush force Tooth penetration Grip strength Grip stamina Grip weight Shake vigour Slashing damage Bite accuracy Bite speed/reflex Senses-Near sight Far sight Near scent Far scent Fresh scent Cold scent Ground scent Air scent Hearing acuity Mental-Problem solving Trainability Determination Independence Courage Docility Affability Composure selflessness Decisiveness Perception Alertness Social skills Bush Smarts Killer instinct Self preservation ------------------  ?? |
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 29, 2023 2:29:06 GMT
Using that template, I'll run some dogs through it, starting with the wolf.
Northern Timberwolf
Body-
Skin durability - 30
feet durability - 85
Bone durability - 35
Skull durability - 93
Coat durability - 83
Muscle/fat durability - 40
Agility - 65
Jumping - 70
Flexibility - 65
Explosivity - 50
Power - 70
Power-to-Weight - 60
Endurance - 95
Energy - 95
Height/Length - 98
Mass - 70
"Fuel" Economy - 98
Pain tolerance - 30
Cold tolerance - 97
Heat tolerance - 85
Running-
Top speed - 91
Acceleration - 60
Sprint sustenation - 65
Lateral Movement - 77
Long distance - 92
Mouth-
Snap force - 97
Crush force - 95
Tooth penetration - 97
Grip strength - 55
Grip stamina - 55
Grip weight - 75
Shake vigour - 77
Slashing damage - 89
Bite accuracy - 88
Bite speed/reflex - 94
Senses-
Near sight - 70
Far sight - 85
Near scent - 85
Far scent - 87
Fresh scent - 91
Cold scent - 84
Ground scent - 96
Air scent - 92
Hearing acuity - 94
Mental-
Problem solving - 97
Trainability - 10
Determination - 50
Independence - 99
Courage - 40
Docility - 15
Affability - 10
Composure - 45
selflessness - 55
Decisiveness - 85
Perception - 97
Alertness - 98
Social skills - 75
Bush Smarts - 100
Killer instinct - 93
Self preservation - 97
Overall
74.5
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 29, 2023 2:45:39 GMT
The all around best dog in my honest opinion is the German shepherd.
|
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 29, 2023 2:50:17 GMT
Siberian Husky
Body-
Skin durability - 50
feet durability - 94
Bone durability - 45
Skull durability - 75
Coat durability - 89
Muscle/fat durability - 50
Agility - 88
Jumping - 70
Flexibility - 70
Explosivity - 50
Power - 45
Power-to-Weight - 65
Endurance - 97
Energy - 97
Height/Length - 50
Mass - 50
"Fuel" Economy - 98
Pain tolerance - 35
Cold tolerance - 99
Heat tolerance - 78
Running-
Top speed - 81
Acceleration - 63
Sprint sustenation - 65
Lateral Movement - 87
Long distance - 96
Mouth-
Snap force - 60
Crush force - 55
Tooth penetration - 57
Grip strength - 30
Grip stamina - 40
Grip weight - 40
Shake vigour - 77
Slashing damage - 77
Bite accuracy - 85
Bite speed/reflex - 97
Senses-
Near sight - 75
Far sight - 75
Near scent - 75
Far scent - 75
Fresh scent - 76
Cold scent - 70
Ground scent - 75
Air scent - 77
Hearing acuity - 95
Mental-
Problem solving - 94
Trainability - 25
Determination - 55
Independence - 85
Courage - 45
Docility - 30
Affability - 25
Composure - 45
selflessness - 60
Decisiveness - 60
Perception - 94
Alertness - 95
Social skills - 70
Bush Smarts - 80
Killer instinct - 85
Self preservation - 91
Overall
68.9
|
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 29, 2023 3:02:50 GMT
The all around best dog in my honest opinion is the German shepherd. Skin durability - 45 feet durability - 80 Bone durability - 50 Skull durability - 89 Coat durability - 80 Muscle/fat durability - 55 Agility - 70 Jumping - 77 Flexibility - 65 Explosivity - 55 Power - 60 Power-to-Weight - 70 Endurance - 86 Energy - 92 Height/Length - 80 Mass - 67 "Fuel" Economy - 88 Pain tolerance - 40 Cold tolerance - 93 Heat tolerance - 85 Running-Top speed - 87 Acceleration - 70 Sprint sustenation - 60 Lateral Movement - 77 Long distance - 80 Mouth-Snap force - 90 Crush force - 85 Tooth penetration - 90 Grip strength - 55 Grip stamina - 60 Grip weight - 69 Shake vigour - 75 Slashing damage - 80 Bite accuracy - 89 Bite speed/reflex - 95 Senses-Near sight - 70 Far sight - 85 Near scent - 85 Far scent - 87 Fresh scent - 91 Cold scent - 84 Ground scent - 96 Air scent - 92 Hearing acuity - 94 Mental-Problem solving - 97 Trainability - 95 Determination - 60 Independence - 70 Courage - 60 Docility - 55 Affability - 55 Composure - 55 selflessness - 88 Decisiveness - 80 Perception - 97 Alertness - 98 Social skills - 75 Bush Smarts - 65 Killer instinct - 75 Self preservation - 78 Overall76.2 |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 29, 2023 3:11:58 GMT
The all around best dog in my honest opinion is the German shepherd. Skin durability - 45 feet durability - 80 Bone durability - 50 Skull durability - 89 Coat durability - 80 Muscle/fat durability - 55 Agility - 70 Jumping - 77 Flexibility - 65 Explosivity - 55 Power - 60 Power-to-Weight - 70 Endurance - 86 Energy - 92 Height/Length - 80 Mass - 67 "Fuel" Economy - 88 Pain tolerance - 40 Cold tolerance - 93 Heat tolerance - 85 Running-Top speed - 87 Acceleration - 70 Sprint sustenation - 60 Lateral Movement - 77 Long distance - 80 Mouth-Snap force - 90 Crush force - 85 Tooth penetration - 90 Grip strength - 55 Grip stamina - 60 Grip weight - 69 Shake vigour - 75 Slashing damage - 80 Bite accuracy - 89 Bite speed/reflex - 95 Senses-Near sight - 70 Far sight - 85 Near scent - 85 Far scent - 87 Fresh scent - 91 Cold scent - 84 Ground scent - 96 Air scent - 92 Hearing acuity - 94 Mental-Problem solving - 97 Trainability - 95 Determination - 60 Independence - 70 Courage - 60 Docility - 55 Affability - 55 Composure - 55 selflessness - 88 Decisiveness - 80 Perception - 97 Alertness - 98 Social skills - 75 Bush Smarts - 65 Killer instinct - 75 Self preservation - 78 Overall76.2 Where are you getting these numbers? Have you even owned a GSD? |
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 29, 2023 3:17:24 GMT
Border Collie
Body-
Skin durability - 45
feet durability - 88
Bone durability - 45
Skull durability - 45
Coat durability - 45
Muscle/fat durability - 50
Agility - 99
Jumping - 98
Flexibility - 85
Explosivity - 65
Power - 40
Power-to-Weight - 50
Endurance - 98
Energy - 99
Height/Length - 50
Mass - 50
"Fuel" Economy - 99
Pain tolerance - 40
Cold tolerance - 89
Heat tolerance - 89
Running-
Top speed - 91
Acceleration - 94
Sprint sustenation - 93
Lateral Movement - 99
Long distance - 95
Mouth-
Snap force - 50
Crush force - 45
Tooth penetration - 45
Grip strength - 45
Grip stamina - 55
Grip weight - 40
Shake vigour - 85
Slashing damage - 68
Bite accuracy - 96
Bite speed/reflex - 98
Senses-
Near sight - 93
Far sight - 97
Near scent - 75
Far scent - 65
Fresh scent - 75
Cold scent - 65
Ground scent - 60
Air scent - 77
Hearing acuity - 97
Mental-
Problem solving - 99
Trainability - 99
Determination - 80
Independence - 75
Courage - 60
Docility - 65
Affability - 99
Composure - 85
selflessness - 94
Decisiveness - 95
Perception - 98
Alertness - 99
Social skills - 88
Bush Smarts - 65
Killer instinct - 30
Self preservation - 88
Overall
74.8
|
|
|
|
Post by Hardcastle on Apr 29, 2023 3:18:05 GMT
German ShepherdBody-Skin durability - 45 feet durability - 80 Bone durability - 50 Skull durability - 89 Coat durability - 80 Muscle/fat durability - 55 Agility - 70 Jumping - 77 Flexibility - 65 Explosivity - 55 Power - 60 Power-to-Weight - 70 Endurance - 86 Energy - 92 Height/Length - 80 Mass - 67 "Fuel" Economy - 88 Pain tolerance - 40 Cold tolerance - 93 Heat tolerance - 85 Running-Top speed - 87 Acceleration - 70 Sprint sustenation - 60 Lateral Movement - 77 Long distance - 80 Mouth-Snap force - 90 Crush force - 85 Tooth penetration - 90 Grip strength - 55 Grip stamina - 60 Grip weight - 69 Shake vigour - 75 Slashing damage - 80 Bite accuracy - 89 Bite speed/reflex - 95 Senses-Near sight - 70 Far sight - 85 Near scent - 85 Far scent - 87 Fresh scent - 91 Cold scent - 84 Ground scent - 96 Air scent - 92 Hearing acuity - 94 Mental-Problem solving - 97 Trainability - 95 Determination - 60 Independence - 70 Courage - 60 Docility - 55 Affability - 55 Composure - 55 selflessness - 88 Decisiveness - 80 Perception - 97 Alertness - 98 Social skills - 75 Bush Smarts - 65 Killer instinct - 75 Self preservation - 78 Overall76.2 Where are you getting these numbers? Have you even owned a GSD? One doesn't just "question" my dog knowledge like this. Is this guy serious? |
|
??